A General Walkthrough of a Guided Case-Law Search
This page describes, in general terms, how a step-by-step guided search generally went in the earlier website. It is a description of a past approach, not a set of instructions. This guide has no search tool, so nothing here can be carried out on this site.
Stage one: choosing a starting point
A guided search usually began with broad criteria. A person might pick the country whose decisions were of interest, and perhaps the country the claimant came from. Choosing a claimant's origin is a good example of how narrowing worked: once a single country was picked, only decisions involving people from there stayed in the pool.
Stage two: adding legal themes
Next came the subject matter. Two kinds of label were commonly offered.
- Outline numbers. Each decision was linked to numbered headings that followed the structure of a well-known textbook on the refugee definition. The headings ran from the origins of the definition through alienage, genuine risk, persecution and the connection to a protected ground, to cessation and exclusion. Numbers allowed a search by theme even when decisions did not share particular phrases.
- Concepts. These were looser tags. Some described kinds of claim, such as those involving arbitrary arrest, gender, or entry without documents. Others described points of interpretation, such as the benefit of the doubt, causation, or the idea of direct flight from danger.
More than one concept could usually be combined, which narrowed the list further.
Stage three: court level and dates
Further filters could separate decisions by the type of body that made them and by the year. This mattered because higher courts generally have more influence, and because older rulings may have been replaced.
Stage four: reading the result list
The outcome was a list of matching decisions, each with a short summary and basic details such as the country, the court and the date. Readers generally scanned summaries first and opened full texts only for the most relevant items. If the list was too long, adding another filter shortened it. If it was empty, removing one filter widened it again.
Why the process mattered
The point of the stages was to move from a very large body of decisions to a handful that addressed one question. For the general idea behind the filters, see the page on guided searching. A different style of looking things up is described under quick search.
Laws and decisions change and differ between countries. This is general information, not legal advice.